| Blind Score | Bottle | Name |
|---|---|---|
| 90.64 |  | Michter's Barrel Strength Rye |
| 88.25 |  | Smooth Ambler Old Scout "Mythical Beast" |
| 87.47 |  | William LaRue Weller - 2017 Release |
| 87.13 |  | Knob Creek Single Barrel #1 - Cleveland Bourbon Club Pick "CBC 4" |
| 87.06 |  | Old Weller Original 107 "gold vein" (Stitzel-Weller) |
| 87.06 |  | Elijah Craig 23 Year Single Barrel |
| 86.81 |  | Wild Turkey 8 Yr 101 (1995) |
| 86.69 |  | Booker's - 1987 (1st national release) |
| 86.65 |  | Willett Family Estate Rye 8 Yr |
| 86.29 |  | Evan Williams 23 Year |
| 86.09 |  | Old Potrero Hotaling's 16 Year Old Single Malt Rye Whiskey |
| 85.80 |  | Blanton's Straight from the Barrel |
| 85.63 |  | Old Fitzgerald 1849 8yr 1990 |
| 85.53 |  | Evan Williams 15 Year |
| 85.33 |  | Elijah Craig Barrel Proof - B517 |
| 85.13 |  | Wild Turkey Master's Keep Decades |
| 85.07 |  | Colonel E.H. Taylor Cured Oak |
| 85.40 |  | Basil Hayden 8 Yr (1992) |
| 84.92 |  | Booker's 25th Anniversary (2014) |
| 84.88 |  | Knob Creek Single Barrel #3 - Cleveland Bourbon Club Pick "Brioche" |
| 84.78 |  | Jim Beam Distiller’s Masterpiece Port Finish - 20 Year Old |
| 84.47 |  | Jack Daniel's Single Barrel, Barrel Proof - 131.9 |
| 84.29 |  | Hochstadter's Family Reserve 16 Yr Rye Whiskey |
| 84.00 |  | Old Rip Van Winkle - 10yr, 2017 |
| 83.77 |  | Little Book - Batch #1 (2017) |
| 83.69 |  | Smooth Ambler Old Scout "Fat Unicorn" |
| 83.88 |  | Old Weller Antique - Party Source Single Barrel #40 |
| 83.35 |  | Whistle Pig 10 Yr Rye Whiskey - Single Barrel |
| 83.29 |  | Bomberger's Declaration - Batch 2 |
| 83.24 |  | Elijah Craig - CBC Pick "Emergency Session" |
| 83.11 |  | Jim Beam Distillers' Masterpiece Cognac Finish - 18 Year Old |
| 82.93 |  | Colonel E.H. Taylor Four Grain |
| 82.71 |  | Lock Stock & Barrel 16 Yr Rye Whiskey |
| 82.53 |  | William Heaven Hill BiB 11 Yr Small Batch - 2014 Release |
| 82.53 |  | Evan Williams 12 Year |
| 82.32 |  | Colonel EH Taylor Seasoned Wood |
| 81.82 |  | Thomas H. Handy - Buffalo Trace Antique Collection |
| 81.63 |  | Rebel Yell 10 Year Single Barrel |
| 81.63 |  | Abraham Bowman Wheat Bourbon - Release #14 |
| 81.42 |  | Buffalo Trace Experimental |
| 81.00 |  | William Heaven Hill 14 yr Single Barrel |
| 81.00 |  | Old Charter 8 Yr (2012) |
| 80.47 |  | Blanton's Gold |
| 80.06 |  | Old Ripy Bourbon - Batch #1 |
| 80.04 |  | Old Heaven Hill 8 Yr (2013) |
| 79.93 |  | Woodford Reserve Double Oaked |
| 79.44 |  | Bond & Lillard Bourbon - Batch #1 |
| 79.29 |  | Buffalo Trace Organic Six Grain Whiskey |
| 78.35 |  | Old Overholt Rye -1974 |
| 78.31 |  | Barrell Whiskey Batch 004 |
| 78.26 |  | Buffalo Trace - Cleveland Bourbon Club #17 "Dead Heat" - Freshly cracked bottle |
| 78.21 | | Buffalo Trace - Cleveland Bourbon Club #17 "Dead Heat" - Opened for 4 days |
| 78.00 |  | Jim Beam Single Barrel |
| 76.94 |  | Barrell Bourbon Batch 011 |
| 76.82 |  | Elijah Craig 18 Year Single Barrel |
| 76.75 |  | Eagle Rare - Cleveland Bourbon Club Pick |
| 76.93 |  | Wathen's Barrel Proof - Single Barrel Pick from Jack Rose |
| 76.88 |  | Black Maple Hill NAS |
| 76.06 |  | Very Olde St. Nick - Batch 12 |
| 75.88 |  | Belle Meade Bourbon Cognac Cask Finish |
| 75.75 |  | Cleveland Whiskey |
| 74.93 |  | Woodford Reserve Toasted Oak Rye |
| 74.41 |  | Barrell Bourbon Batch 010 |
| 72.47 |  | Blanton's Green |
| 69.29 |  | A.D. Laws Four Grain Straight Bourbon |
Whiskey: The Blind Truth
